He's
Hunter Hearst Helmsley. He's supposed to be the best in the business*1, the top of the pile of what a wrestler should be, so why is a check in the loss column one of the greatest things that's happened to him recently?
The answer's not so simple. At Wrestlemania XX, Chris Benoit got what was coming to him, the world heavyweight title. Triple H got a big loss at the biggest stage of the year, the grand-daddy of them all. Finally, someone had bested Triple H and taken the title from him, not an easy thing to do. The title reign Hunter had killed superstars in the WWE. Scott Steiner was left att the wayside, Goldberg was a victim but held the title for two months, Kevin Nash was a victim, Michaels was able to hold the title for a month as well, but eventually gave it back. The title reign survived such atrocities as the arm wrestling match with Scott Steiner, the never actually happened bench pressing competition with Steiner, an Elimination Chamber, a Hell in the Cell with Kevin Nash, but Benoit took the gold and ran with it.
So why is it so good that he lost the title? It's not so much that he simply lost it, but more
how he lost it. He tapped out in middle of the ring, without being attacked by someone who wasn't involved in the match. He tapped out.
And instantly the crowd, including mysef and my friends also attending, exploded into celebration. Was it that Benoit had finallly gotten hold of the title? That was only part of the celebration. Triple H had finally decicevly lost to someone. It was all that much sweeter that it was Benoit.
And then it all happened the next night, which I was also a part of. No, not the announcement of the RAW that Vince McMahon was going to "shake things up"*2 with the draft lottery, the crowd started chanting the first time Triple H showed his beak in the Continental Airlines Arena.
"You tapped out! You tapped out!"
Simple and to the point, but it was the first chant that I can remember the crowd creating in a long time. Another that comes to mind is "Shane's a pussy!" and the Kurt Andgle "You Suck"*3 The New Jersey/New York crowd started chanting, and would not stop. So again, why's this good for Triple H?
Because he'll always claim to be the best. He'll claim that no one can beat him, and the crowd will always remember that at Wrestlemania XX, someone did just that. Any time that he mentions that he's the best, the masses will remind him that he tapped out. Everyone will remeember that when faced with the pain of the crippler crossface, simply bearing the pain until he could once again reach his way to the ropes, he gave in. His title was on the line. The one thing that mattered most to him was on the line. If he could only bear the pain that Benoit was dishing out, he could walk away from what would be, without a shadow of a doubt, his biggest victory to date. Bigger than his August 23rd 1999 victory over Mankind where he won his first world title. Bigger than his 1997 victory over Mannkind to earn the King of the Ring status. Bigger than his April 29th 2001 tag title win with Steve Austin over the Undertaker and Kane to become the second ever Grand Slam Champion. You get the picture, so why?
Because this was Wrestlemania XX, the biggest Wrestlemania to date.*4
So until the day that the fans forget that he lost at Wrestlemania XX, he'll always be reminded that he tapped out when it was all on the line in front of people in 90 different countries around the world, and in front of the 20,000 fans from 16 different countries.
It's simple, he tapped out. And the crowd picked up on that it doesn't happen all that often. So they'll remind him at every opportunity they get.
*1 Yes, of course Ric flair is the best, but certainly not as a performer. Ad again, yes Bret art is the best there is the best there was and the best there ever will be, but let us not digress
*2 Vince's previous announcements have included that he was going to go home to be a "genetic jackhammer" as well, so we were all a
tad bit skeptical
*3 I'll have to double check that, I remember Edge egging the crowd on the chant it during his music, but I'm not sure if the crowd started it.
*4 Each current one is, isn't it?